Every November, the UK’s biggest retailers compete to make the nation feel something, and every year the films get bigger, the budgets get heavier and the question gets harder to dodge: who is all this for? Polly Hopkins, Managing Director of Elmwood London, has a clear view. In this piece, she looks at what the 2026 Christmas ads reveal about the gap between looking generous and understanding what shoppers are going through, and names the one campaign she thinks got the balance right.

Retailers don't need to spend less on Christmas advertising. They need to stop confusing expensive-looking advertising with generosity.
That is the real warning in OnePulse research for Retail Gazette, which found that 57% of UK consumers would rather retailers cut Christmas ad spend and pass the savings on through lower prices. People haven't fallen out of love with a good Christmas film. They've fallen out of patience with brands that make festive excess look like emotional understanding.
The best ads this year have grasped the distinction. They don't pretend money is irrelevant. They make the brand useful to the story, and they find pleasure in the imperfect reality of the season.
That is a harder brief than making people cry.
The effective Christmas ad has one job: earn its production budget
A Christmas ad can be lavish. It just can't be lavish for its own sake.
John Lewis's Gloria and Pickles, created by Saatchi & Saatchi, understands a real family tension. A grandparent gives cash because choosing a gift has become difficult. Kristin Scott Thomas's Gloria takes that as a challenge and turns her London study into a disco-lit "Gran Cave", while Paul Whitehouse's Pickles delivers the provocation: "You can do better than cash."
It is funny, warm and expertly made. System1 gave it 5.6 stars, John Lewis's strongest score since Excitable Edgar in 2019, and 61% of viewers said it made them happy. It is currently top of AdRanking's 2026 table, and The Drum reported that only 6% of viewers really disliked it.
But it also exposes the problem with much Christmas advertising. "You can do better than cash" lands differently when cash is tight. The answer on offer is a fully transformed room in a London home, set to Sam Fender's cover of You Can't Always Get What You Want. Kantar suggested the ad lacked punch. The bigger issue is that its gesture of thoughtfulness is dressed in the visual language of abundance.
The film isn't wrong to celebrate effort. It's wrong to make effort look expensive.
That is the line retailers must toe this year. Audiences will accept fantasy. They won't accept a brand treating their financial pressure as a creative inconvenience.
Morrisons gets closer than most. Its Goldilocks film, Christmas Made Just Right, by Leo UK, by is built around things being slightly off. The tree leans. Place settings don't match. Goldilocks's chair is broken. Daddy Bear needs help from the Market Street fishmonger to get the salmon right. None of this is framed as a compromise or a failure. It's Christmas as many people actually experience it: assembled, improvised and still worth celebrating.
Value belongs in the story, not bolted on afterwards
The false choice facing retailers is usually framed as lavish storytelling or value. It's a lazy distinction.
Value isn't a supersized price flash in the final three seconds. It's a point of view about what the brand understands. Morrisons says that "just right" can be better than perfect. Asda has gone in the opposite direction with All of Christmas at Asda Price. BOOM!, choosing high-energy shopping occasions over festive sentiment. Argos pairs Richard Ayoade's Scrooge-like character with practical reasons to shop: range, convenience, value and availability.
Those films make different creative choices, but they share a commercial discipline. They don't ask consumers to forget what Christmas costs.
My Christmas ad of the year: The National Lottery
Every retailer is trying to sell a bigger Christmas to people with less to spend. The National Lottery deals with that tension more directly than any of them, because what it sells is the hope of having more.
VCCP's This Christmas It Could Be You is simple. A reindeer watches a robin take off and decides it wants to fly. It fails, tries again, fails again, and finally lifts off over a snowy landscape. A rambler sees it happen and reaches for his pink National Lottery ticket. Then Claudia Winkleman closes it: "Amazing things happen when you believe. This Christmas it could be you."
Nothing in the film looks expensive. There's no townhouse, no transformed room and no table piled with food. The payoff is an animal doing something impossible and a stranger lucky enough to see it. The emotion comes from effort, and that effort costs nothing. While John Lewis dresses thoughtfulness in abundance, a reindeer falling over in the snow makes the same point better.
The product has a job in the plot, too. The ticket isn't a logo stuck on at the end. It's what the rambler reaches for at the moment he's seen proof that anything is possible. That one gesture shows the brand's whole role.
It also makes an old line feel new. "It could be you" has belonged to The National Lottery for decades. Here it isn't a jackpot claim. It's the end of a story about not giving up, and a reindeer, the most Christmas animal there is, turns a familiar line into a seasonal one.
The risk is obvious. A lottery ad in a cost-of-living Christmas can look like selling hope to people who are short of money. The film is restrained about it. It's about belief, and its big moment is a reindeer in the air rather than a pile of cash. That restraint is why it works. A brand with that much potential for excess chose a small, earned moment instead, and that is the lesson for everyone else's Christmas budget.








