We have twelve versions. What are we waiting for?




Published

We have twelve versions. What are we waiting for?

By Marta Rogna

The meeting is nearly over when someone says:

Could we see a few more options?

It is a familiar request in creative work. Sometimes it is exactly the right one. The idea needs pushing. Something hasn’t landed. There is a better answer somewhere, and the team knows it.

Other times, the room goes quiet because there are already twelve versions.

We have explored the warmer direction, the simpler direction, the one closer to the brand guidelines and the one that challenges them. We have revisited the original route, which everyone now remembers rather more fondly.

What would a thirteenth version help us decide?

As creative tools make exploration faster, I think we will need to become much better at answering that question.

Another version is a small request

From a distance, another version rarely looks like much.

A different image. A shorter edit. A change of tone.

Inside a project, it sets several things in motion. Someone interprets the feedback. Someone makes the work. Someone checks it. Other people review it, sometimes without having seen the previous discussion.

By the next meeting, the team may be responding to several different interpretations of the same request.

AI can shorten parts of that process considerably. A visual direction can become tangible much earlier. Teams can test something they might otherwise have had neither the time nor the budget to explore.

That is useful. It also makes “let’s see another option” an increasingly easy thing to say.

The effort involved in producing a version may fall. The attention required to assess it still has to come from somewhere.

Ideas in progress: a hand behind a glass wall of colourful notes

Feedback tells you where the uncertainty is

One of the most useful things a Creative Project Manager can do is listen carefully to an apparently simple comment.

It needs more impact.

That could mean the product is getting lost. It could mean the work feels too familiar. It could mean the person reviewing it is worried about presenting it to someone more senior.

Each calls for a different response.

Starting another round before understanding the concern can keep a team busy for days.

I have learnt to ask a few more questions at that point. What feels unresolved? Where does the work stop doing what we need it to do? Is there a particular part we should look at together?

There is a way to have that conversation without making anyone feel interrogated. It starts with accepting that people can recognise a problem before they have the language to explain it.

Helping them articulate it is part of moving the work forward.

A decision needs an owner

Creative work attracts opinions. A campaign may involve people responsible for the brand, the market, the product, the channel and the budget. Their perspectives matter.

The difficulty comes when the team has to work out how those perspectives fit together.

If one person wants more detail and another wants simplicity, the next version can easily become an attempt to accommodate both. A little gets added here. Something is reduced there. The result comes back to the room, where nobody feels their concern has quite been addressed.

Before asking people to revise the work again, we need to establish who can resolve that tension and on what basis.

That conversation is easier to have at the beginning of a project. It remains worth having halfway through.

In my experience, seniority in project management includes being willing to raise it.

Brainstorming in progress: handwritten ideas on pink notes

Moving between markets taught me to ask

Working across London, Amsterdam, Paris and Milan has made me cautious about assuming that a shared brief means a shared understanding.

People bring different expectations about how work should be presented, how directly they can challenge it and when a decision becomes final.

A quiet meeting can leave you with very little information.

Did everyone agree? Did someone need more time? Was a concern left unspoken because the right person wasn’t there?

I try to leave important conversations with a clear understanding of what has been agreed, what remains open and who will take the next step.

It sounds straightforward. On a complex project, it takes attention every time.

Speed changes what we need to protect

There is a temptation to use every saving in production time to fit in more exploration.

Sometimes that is a good choice. Sometimes the time would be better spent letting people look properly at the work.

A creative team needs an opportunity to explain why a route is worth pursuing. A client may need to resolve an internal disagreement. A producer may need to investigate whether one crucial detail can actually be achieved.

These activities are harder to display than a new set of visuals. They can have a much greater effect on the outcome.

As tools become faster, I want to be more deliberate about where the saved time goes.

Discarded ideas: crumpled yellow paper beside a wastebasket

The question before the next round

I enjoy the point in a project when a team commits to a direction. The conversations become more precise. People begin solving the particular problems of making that idea work.

Getting there requires room to explore, and enough clarity to recognise when exploration has done its job.

So when someone asks for another option, I think there is a useful question to put on the table:

What do we need to learn from the next version?

If we can answer it, we have given the team something to work with.

If we struggle, that may be the conversation we need to have before anyone opens another file.

Comments